Email this page to a friend!

Where does my money go - Child Sponsorship

 

Have you ever wondered where your money goes after making a donation? In this series of blogs, GPP co-founder Simon Moss explores how you can understand where it goes, why, and how you can help it go further.

Ja’mie King proudly shows the camera around her room, beaming at her record as the person with the highest number of sponsor children in the country – 83. Although she’s just a character in Chris Lilley’s mockumentary series’ We Can Be Heroes and Summer Heights High, she’s a prime example of a child sponsor, the most common and highest grossing source of donating to aid agencies.

A few years ago, I was leading a high school camp, and upon hearing that I worked in the aid sector, I was asked by Sam, a year 10 student how child sponsorship worked. They and their family had a child for years, and although he thought it was great, he didn’t understand how his sponsor brother got the money they sent each month.

As I explained that the neither his sponsor brother or his family actually got the money, Sam’s face turned to anger. “What do you mean they don’t get the money? Do they spend it all in administration? I knew it!” Trying to placate him as we picked through rocks on a steep ascent, I clarified.

I said that no, the money wasn’t wasted. The vast majority of the money is spent in the local community on things that the family wants and needs – like books for the school, nurses for the health clinic, maintenance for the water pump and on extra nutrition programs and support for the community.

I went on to explain that it makes no sense to hand out the money to individual children and families, as that’s not how these communities work. Resources are shared amongst many people, and it won’t work for everyone to have a tiny bit of money for water. Instead, we need to pay for the whole system, and the most efficient and effective way to do that is to pool resources, and make things available for everyone.

It’s how we do many things in our own countries with services provided by the government. And, it’s often the only way of providing services to the poorest of the poor, who would otherwise never get the opportunity to go to school or get to see a doctor.

Nodding his head, Sam had just one more question. “Why is it then that I get told I’m sponsoring a child when I’m actually sponsoring a community?” I was puffing by now, exhausted from climbing a hill laden with a rucksack whilst explaining how child sponsorship worked. So, I paused for a moment, considered how to say it, then continued;

“Because most people don’t want to have a ten minute discussion about their donation before they give it. They want to know that it’s going to make a real difference in someone’s life, that as a direct result of their gift, a child will get to learn to read and write. We connect with individuals and stories of people like us doing the things that we do, not numbers and graphs about the proportion of villagers with access to clean drinking water.”

I finished by noting that when we explain things completely, people get bored, wander off, and don’t donate. That’s not helpful to the charity trying to fundraise, and it’s certainly not helpful for the kids, families and communities who stand to benefit when we do choose to give.To learn more about how poverty affects children, read here.

If you’d like to become a child sponsor, contact your local Plan, World Vision, Save the Children or Compassion office today.

Comments

09/11/09 5:26am - Posted By NigePresto - Reply to this comment
Nice post Simon,
An excellent and well balanced explanation of the system behind the child sponsorship process.
Your points here reflect my understanding of how Child Sponsorship works and I believe in this format it is actually a lot more effective than if it was individual one-to-one support.

BUT - I wonder whether (some) Australians have matured in their understanding of poverty and development to a point where we could do away with the facade - OR - maybe people still don't have or want to spend that 10 minutes to listen, discuss and understand what they are actually signing up for.

I look forward to the rest of the series.
09/11/09 9:18pm - Posted By Simon Moss - Reply to this comment
A quick addition to the above - the same questions have just been asked of www.kiva.org, the micro-lending website.

For an overview, see the New York Times article at http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/09/business/global/09kiva.html?em

For the original blog that started the discussion, see http://blogs.cgdev.org/open_book/2009/10/kiva-is-not-quite-what-it-seems.php

If there's interest, I'll dig around and post more on this - let us know,

Simon
02/08/10 2:47am - Posted By genie guardado - Reply to this comment
Hello there,
You guys are into something great :)
Pencils and recyclable paper-amomg the basics so those children will have a better future tthough education.
Congratulations on your noble efforts!

I would also love to add that maybe in the long run wouldn't some chalkboards and chalk ( or the most modern ones -whiteboards with markers) be a more effective tool when it comes to do repetitive exercises such as Arithmetic,,Math, Agebra and the like..After all necessary drills are finished ( done on small blackboards or little white boards) only then, they could copy a couple or more of exercises in their notebooks, saving themselves some paper and pencils?

I have some questions ::
Are you guys trying to get those pencils from USA to Africa?
If so- did you guys know that UA (Unted Airlines) flies illegal immigants back to their countries of origin paid by US Governemt at a discount rate? Maybe if approached by you, they would be willing to do this at a huge discount or maybe for free? Or if UA doesnt fly or make connections there , we can then research what other Airlines would be interested in helping out?

If flying those pencils is not an option, how about sending them by freight-wouldn't this be less costly?

Why only Africa? There are lots od Third World Countries on this planet.
Don't take me wrong, I 'm a firm beleiver of the maxim : "We're all interconnected. "But I have been noticing a pattern (Campaign ONE -for example and now you)
I know Africa is among one of the poorest countries, and they deserve all the help they can get, but there are lots of countries-in simliar or worst conditions- that get overlooked

I once read about an organization that for each lap-top bought in America,they would match it tup with buying a Lap-top to an African youth.Are you aware which organization is this? I'll try to find out and keep you posted!

Also have you checked out Bill Gates? I've eard he's an extremely altruistic individual,,maybe he would donate some lap-tos and computers too?

This might sound off the wall, but how about uniting efforts? I heard that Medecins Sans Frontiers own their planes and just maybe they would be willing to fly those pencils with them?

Thanks for your patience.
Best wishes,!
Genie Guardado
gigiguardado@yahoo.com
08/08/12 2:30am - Posted By Mitch Spector - Reply to this comment
Support this amazing organization in the world wide effort to end poverty !.This is a labor of love and is God's work .

Add Comment

Your Name:

Your Email (Not Displayed):

Please enter the code in the image into the box

Code:


Can't read the image? Reload